About this Show

Erin Burnett Out Front

News/Business. Erin Burnett. (2012) New.

NETWORK
CNN

DURATION
01:00:00

RATING

SCANNED IN
San Francisco, CA, USA

SOURCE
Comcast Cable

TUNER
Virtual Ch. 759 (CNN HD)

VIDEO CODEC
mpeg2video

AUDIO CODEC
ac3

PIXEL WIDTH
1920

PIXEL HEIGHT
1080

TOPIC FREQUENCY

U.s. 16, Us 15, America 11, Bill Clinton 10, Erin 9, Libya 8, United States 6, Clinton 5, Benghazi 5, Florida 5, Obama 4, Mohammed 4, Egypt 3, Israel 3, Mark Zuckerberg 3, Romney 3, Mitt Romney 2, Barack Obama 2, Massmutual 2, Phil 2,
Borrow a DVD
of this show
  CNN    Erin Burnett Out Front    News/Business. Erin  
   Burnett.  (2012) New.  

    September 11, 2012
    4:00 - 5:00pm PDT  

4:00pm
4:00 or 5:00 in the afternoon seemed to me like 1,000 construction workers did he sdended on ground zero. the place was on flames and these guys wanted to go in and drag people out. >> the full interview, 9:00 p.m. eastern. erin burnett "outfront" starts right now. >> "outfront," next. an american consulate storm, a flag destroyed at an american embassy and massive protest at a surprising location. we have breaking news tonight. bill clinton also hitting the stump tonight for president obama, going after a very specific time p type of voter. and a new warning that puts the united states really sort of in a greek myth, between the ultimate rock and a hard place. let's go "outfront." good evening, everyone, i'm erwin burnet. outfront tonight, we have breaking news. an american we can confirm now
4:01pm
has been killed in libya tonight at the consulate, according to a libyan interior ministry official. this is a horrible result of a day of violence against america in the middle east. armed men stormed the american consulate in benghazi libya, tonight, setting it on fire after a protest against an american-produced movie they say insults the prophet, mohammed. this was just hours after egyptian protesters scaled the was of the american embassy in cairo, tearing down the american flag. the protesters there tried to raise a black flag, with the words "there is no god, but alla and mohammed is his messenger." we're in cairo with the latest on the situation. ian, obviously, we're sad to confirm that breaking news on an american who has been killed and the violence in libya. but the outburst you saw in cairo sounds like it got ugly quickly. what exactly happened? >> reporter: well, erin, i was on the ground, and i saw hundreds if not a couple
4:02pm
thousand protesters in front of the u.s. embassy, chanting against america. a handful of protesters were able to reach the perimeter of the embassy and tear down the american flag, and then set it on fire. these protesters are angry about that video you mentioned earlier. and this video, i watched this video, and it's really pretty much incoherent, a mishmash of clips. but what it does show, it shows the prophet mohammed, the muslim prophet, as being someone who is a homosexual, as someone who is a womanizer, someone who month left children. basically everything possible that muslims would find offensive. and really, things that have no historical credibility, either, erin. >> certainly those sound like awful things. you understand why that would upset people, although transcritranslat translating into burning the country's flag very different. we were able to confirm the
4:03pm
breaking news, ian, an american was killed in violence in libya moments ago. were there any americans in the embassy in cairo who were at risk? >> reporter: approximate well, yes, there are americans in the embassy, the ambassador lives in the embassy. there's also a large detachment of marines who live in the embassy, one of the largest in the world. but them because, i've been to it many times, it is a well-fortified embassy, despite the protesters able to make it into the courtyard, it would be very, very unlikely they would be able to actually penetrate or enter the buildings that consist of the embassy, erin. >> and ian, has the egyptian government or president more see, obviously the leader of the muslim brotherhood, a conservative, islamic government. has he said anything about the incident? has he apologized, or no? >> reporter: the foreign ministry actually came out and said they regret what happened and that they're going to look into it. they're talking to every
4:04pm
ministry that's involved in security to talk about how they would allow this to happen. we did see security forces show up later. they were able to block the protesters from e embassy. but erwin, this is something we have seen before, we sea earlier the syrian embassy. this is the third embassy breached, the first one under president morecy, but definitel a security concern that egyptian officials have to bring up. >> reporting live from cairo, as the american flag was burnt by the embassy. the incidents in cairo and benghazi, the latest examples of anti-american sentiment in the middle east. but what do they mean for this country going forward? phil mudd is former director of the cia counter terrorist center and he is "outfront" tonight. phil, when we talk about this today, i'll go ahead and mention what feels like the elephant in the room. obviously, today is september 11th, a very somber day in this country. these incidents happened in both cairo and libya today. both have been linkeded to the
4:05pm
movie that allegedly mocks the prophet mohammed andeen said it said some horrible things. it is coincidence or intentional these happened on september 11th? >> my guess is could i incidence. this looks like those cartoons in denmark where you had unrest in afghanistan and pakistan. i think the coincidence of the date is just that, coincidence. >> let me bring in ed hussein, as well. senior fellow of middle eastern studies and the council on foreign relations. ed, thanks for taking the time to be with us, as well. what does this mean for the united states? i mean, obviously, tension is high. but what is the significance of this happening in two places on the same day against the u.s.? >> well, i think i'm in agreement with phil. this is not a coincidence. this is by design. but i think several things stand out. one, that the narrative that the arab spring was all led by liberal secularists and how the middle east is now warm and
4:06pm
friendly towards america and american ideals, that narrative no longer holds true, if it ever did. >> right. >> there are people on the fringes who are able to impact the center of political debate with this kind of outrageous activity. and now what they will turn around and say to you, the prophet mohammed is a red light, mohammed is a red light, they fail to cross that. they can't distinguish between free citizens and a free country doing whatever they wish to please. and the government of the country, in this case, the u.s., is irresponsible and innocent of anything that happens. but this is part of the problem in the middle east, they can't distinguish between independent citizens and the role of the governments. that's part of the legacy of living under a dictatorship for so many years. >> phil, i'm wondering, was this just disorganization, or looking the other way? because the american embassy was involved. i mean, why were there not more egyptian security forces there to prevent them skalg the walls and burning the american flag? >> my guess is they have a plan to respond to this, but they're
4:07pm
just not as efficient as we might expect in the west. as somebody mentioned earlier, you've had attacks on different embassies across cairo in the past months. the security services have gone through great disarray since the change in government so they might not have been prepared for this. i'm guessing it also happened very quickly. >> it seems certainly from what ian was reporting that was the case. ed, what about what a lot of americans may ask as a result of this? is which is until america understands who is in charge and what they stand for, given the question marks in cairo, also in libya, how does the u.s. go ahead, giving $1.5 billion in military in aid every year to egypt? most of that is military aid. >> i think one of the important reasons here that the relations between the egyptian government and the current government under mohammed morse see and the white house and the state department and the congress is in good shape is partly to do with that aid. i don't think immediately the question of aid should be put on the table. it's a tiny proportion of the u.s. annual budget that goes out to egypt. for that we get returns.
4:08pm
and those returns include, you know, a peace treaty with israel, better influence over the region, president thus far that's been friendly towards the u.s., potential trade deals. >> you really think we get all that from it? when they were attacking the israeli embassy recently and now crowds attacking the american? we get goodwill from it? >> those are headlines, but the reality on the ground, the peace deal with israel still stands and the government has gone after terrorists. that's unprecedented for an islamist president to go after al qaeda terrorists in egypt. that's worth something. i don't think we should throw the baby out with a bath water because a few extremists have busht a flag. that's exactly what they want and we should not succumb to that pressure from the fringes. >> i understand ed, distinguishing between the two, on the ground and in cairo as we have all experienced. there are plenty of wonderful moments, as well. but where is this heading towards? >> i think this is heading in a direction that's pretty simple to follow. if you look at polling data.
4:09pm
look, like through the rest of the middle east, you've got fewer than 20% of egyptians who have a positive view of the united states. and just about 10% of them think that american cultural representation in a place like cairo is a good thing. so in the midst of that back drop, you throw a match on this tinder box and the form of this video, and unsurprisingly, people who have seen the abu ghraib videos, reports that we burn qurans, decide we don't like america, we're going to burn the embassy. so we have a lot of space to make up in terms of people who don't think america represents what we think it represents. >> right. until those people have jobs and livelihoods of their own, it's hard to break that cycle. thanks so much to both of you. we appreciate it. ahead, bill clinton on the campaign trail tonight for president obama, speaking moments ago. oh, but a double-edged sword. and mark zuckerberg made his first comment since the disastrous launch of the facebook ipo. and he has a plan. we'll tell but it. he has a plan, a plan, a plan.
4:10pm
that's your only hint. and is prime minister netanyahu being snubbed? in america today we're running out of a vital resource we need to compete on the global stage. what we need are people prepared for the careers of our new economy. by 2025 we could have 20 million jobs
4:11pm
without enough college graduates to fill them. that's why at devry university, we're teaming up with companies like cisco to help make sure everyone's ready with the know how we need for a new tomorrow. [ male announcer ] make sure america's ready. make sure you're ready. at devry.edu/knowhow. ♪ at devry.edu/knowhow. fore! no matter what small business you are in, managing expenses seems to... get in the way. not anymore. ink, the small business card from chase introduces jot an on-the-go expense app made exclusively for ink customers. custom categorize your expenses anywhere. save time and get back to what you love. the latest innovation. only for ink customers. learn more at chase.com/ink
4:12pm
to meet the needs of my growing business. but how am i going to fund it? and i have to find a way to manage my cash flow better.
4:13pm
[ female announcer ] our wells fargo bankers are here to listen, offer guidance and provide you with options tailored to your business. we've loaned more money to small businesses than any other bank for ten years running. so come talk to us to see how we can help. wells fargo. together we'll go far. and now our second story "outfront." clinton, the closer. fresh off his star turn at the democratic convention, the former president hit the campaign trail today for president obama and the crucial swing state of florida. >> if you're looking for the future, i think the president's budget plan is better.
4:14pm
meets the arithmetic test. i think the health care plan ist higher education plan is better. i know the energy plan is ani knowhe economic plan is better. and i know it will notmoto a hillf beans if you don't a g your friends to. so do it. >> all right. bill clinton's popularit cret. talk about the ultimat comeback kid, okay? his approval rating is 69%. a new cnn poll puts president obama's approval at 51%. historically now, september numbers are very telling. so let's just look at this. ooh, look at all these little jolly heads. compared to other presidents -- sorry. compared to other presidents, obama is in pretty good shape. george h.w. bush and jimmy carter who both lost had approval ratings in the high 30s at this time of the year so he's way, way above that. but his 51% is lower than the presidents who went on to win,
4:15pm
including clinton with his highwatermark of 60% approval in 1986. good to see all of you. ryan, let's start with you. should republicans be afraid, very, very afraid? of the silver-haired fox? >> i think the key thing is, when you're looking at the states where he's campaigning, it's very shrewd. he's campaigning in florida and also campaigning in ohio. when you're looking at a lot of the swing states, they unemployment rates that are below the national average. and actually, even though the job creation has been sluggish, it has been moving on an upward trend, whereas in the 18 months before the 2010 midterm elections, they were really stuck. so i think that even though the economy is not doing great, it's doing well enough that president obama is still in the fight, and, yeah, bill clinton is more popular than ever, partly because a lot of folks who hated him most are now dead. and a lot of people who were kids when he was a popular president are now voting. >> look what's going on. you look at congress and paul
4:16pm
ryan, newt gingrich, they praise president bill clinton. >> o he's the guy who reached ss the asle adba the buet. >> but the reality is this here. bill clinton is so smooth, he is ableo seduce fo and remember, you heard when he was president,eople saide could walk into a room, and you cahahe guy, and he'll flip you in a minut because i that kind of guy >> the seducer? >> yes. yes. she was in prison and she wouldn't talk for the guy. she said that's the kind of guy he was. are you all forgetting the clinton years? >> no, no, i remember. i remember the good and the bad. >> right. >> that's what i love about this. the fact that bill clinton is now the republicans' favorite democrat is funny. >> didn't we try to impeach this guy? >> yeah. >> i'm making sure we're talking about the same guy. >> and here's the deal. republicans wish -- there is something special when you have a former president out on the stump.
4:17pm
look, president george -- >> i don't see them bringing their guy out. >> here's the deal, president george h.w. bush is ill. president george w. bush is toxic. and they can gets mad all they want, but president bush can't go out there and do it. >> you're in a swing state, you see an ad for the obama campaign that begins with bill clinton. is there a precedent for that? people aren't using w. this time arnlt. everyone invokes reagan but it's not people used carter. >> people took a while to rehabilitate. >> no. >> you never know. >> it took a while. he was not popular when he left office. a lot of people are forgetting the down sides of the clinton years. i personally think he was overrated but he was not overrated as a politician. and the key thing is that president obama needs to slightly close that gap that he has with white voters. and bill clinton is quite popular with a large number of those working-class white voters where you need to close that gap, just a little bit. you're still going to have a big deficit but if you close it just a little bit, suddenly mitt
4:18pm
romney is in real trouble. >> right. there's a reason they call him bubba. bubba connects with bubba. >> 3 for 3 on inappropriate marks. >> 69% approval. that's not just being beloved by the democratic base. that's being beloved by independents, by swing centrists and even some republicans. you've got to win ohio, you've got to win florida. and he's the last democrat to get re-elected. he's a powerhouse on the stump. >> let's remind everybody in 2008, we had this exact same conversation. president then senator obama not doing well with white, blue collar voters during the primary. senator hillary clinton doing well. remember, president bill clinton spoke on wednesday in 2008. he spoke on wednesday in 2012. we're having the exact same conversation. >> ryan, you think president clinton could swing the whole election, right? >> that's a little strong, but i think he's a lot more important in this cycle than in 2008. in 2008, you had massive political and economic head winds working against the
4:19pm
republican candidate. this time around, bill clinton is the star who came out of the democratic national convention that represented a really big significant bounce for president obama. president obama's speech was not the speech that made a difference with a lot of swing voters, with a lot of leaners. it is president clinton's speech, and which this is really, really bizarre and interesting. and i think it means a lot for 2016. >> and it does -- >> 2016 -- >> whoa. >> barack obama -- >> i saw joe scarborough is not going to 2016. he could change his mind. thanks to all three of you. we appreciate it. >> but ba. >> mark zuckerberg has talked about facebook's flop as an ipo but has a plan to get it on track. and what the campaigns know about you. oh, they know what you do online. home of the brave. ♪ it's where fear goes unwelcomed... ♪
4:20pm
and certain men... find a way to rise above. this is the land of giants. ♪ guts. glory. ram. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 like a lot of things, the market has changed, tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 and your plans probably have too. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 at charles schwab, we'll give you personalized recommendations tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 on how to reinvest that old 401(k). tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 so talk to chuck tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 and bring your old 401(k) into the 21st century. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 rollover your 401(k) or ira and receive up to $600.
4:21pm
tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 see schwab.com for terms and conditions. ♪ (train horn) vo: wherever our trains go, the economy comes to life. norfolk southern. one line, infinite possibilities. a thing that helps you wbuy other things.hing. but plenty of companies do that. so we make something else.
4:22pm
we help make life a little easier, more convenient, more rewarding, more entertaining. year after year. it's the reason why we don't have customers. we have member american express. welcome in.
4:23pm
almost four months after the company's ipo, things have been pretty crumby for facebook. trading after its initial trading price at $38 a share. investors have a lot of
4:24pm
questions for mark zuckerberg, the 28-year-old founder and ceo. this was a big deal. today he spoke for the first time. it's been a really long time since he talked. he sat down for an interview at a tech conference in san frcisco. testifies a standing-room-only conversation. he called the stock's performance disappointing and admitted facebook made some mistakes. during the talk, he also explained how he hopes to turn the company around over the next few years, which brings us to tonight's number, 37. that's the number of times mark zuckerberg said the word "mobile" during today's 25-minute interview. >> it's really going to be how well we do with mobile. mobile, mobile, mobile, mobile is for us. facebook mobile users. mobile users. mobile is -- mobile users. on mobile engagement. mobile, mobile, mobile. >> mobile web facebook. to mobile development. mobile app installed. we have more usage on our mobile website. >> mobile. he averaged more than one mobile mention per minute. and that is a lot.
4:25pm
a lot of the time we weren't sure if he was trying to convince wall street or himself. because just because you say something a lot doesn't mean it's actually, you know, going to happen. but at least mark zuckerberg recognizes that investors think facebook has some serious challenges in terms of mobile and he's trying to fix it. and a lot of people are going to applaud that. all right. next, there's a new warning tonight about the consequences of congress doing nothing. but doing nothing might not be the worst option. and why the israeli government is feeling snubbed tonight by president obama. [ female announcer ] they can be enlightening.
4:26pm
hey, bro. or engaging. conversations help us learn and grow. at wells fargo, we believe you can never underestimate the power of a conversation. it's this exchange of ideas that helps you move ahead with confidence. so when the conversation turns to your financial goals... turn to us. if you need anything else, let me know. [ female announcer ] wells fargo. together we'll go far. but proven technologies allow natural gas producers
4:27pm
to supply affordable, cleaner energy, while protecting our environment. across america, these technologies protect air - by monitoring air quality and reducing emissions... ...protect water - through conservation and self-contained recycling systems... ... and protect land - by reducing our footprint and respecting wildlife. america's natural gas... domestic, abundant, clean energy to power our lives... that's smarter power today. ♪ ♪ [ male announcer ] you've been years in the making. and there are many years ahead. join the millions of members who've chosen an aarp medicare supplement insurance plan insured by unitedhealthcare insurance company. go long. his morning starts with arthritis pain.
4:28pm
and two pills. afternoon's overhaul starts with more pain. more pills. triple checking hydraulics. the evening brings more pain. so, back to more pills. almost done, when... hang on. stan's doctor recommended aleve. it can keep pain away all day with fewer pills than tylenol. this is rudy. who switched to aleve. and two pills for a day free of pain. ♪ and get the all day pain relief of aleve in liquid gels. [ male announcer ] how could a luminous protein in jellyfish, impact life expectancy in the u.s., real estate in hong kong, and the optics industry in germany? at t. rowe price, we understand the connections of a complex, global economy. it's just one reason over 70% of our mutual funds beat their 10-year lipper average. t. rowe price. invest with confidence. request a prospectus or summary prospectus with investment information, risks, fees and expenses to read and consider carefully before investing.
4:29pm
we start the second half of our show with stories we care about, focus on our reporting from the front lines. we begin tonight in chicago where 30,000 teachers and staff, it appears, are not close to ending their strike. the chicago teachers union put out a statement this afternoon saying they agreed to only 6 of the 39 terms in the contract. one major holdup, how the city wants to evaluate teachers. they want more emphasis on standardized test scores and pay. rahm emanuel reformed education by extending the school year, cutting the school budget and extending the school day. chicago is the nation's third biggest school district with more than 350,000 students. florida a&m university says it's not responsible for the
4:30pm
hazing death of drum major robert champion. the school has failed to have a wrongful death lawsuit dismissed, saying the 26-year-old should have refused to take part in the hazing. in court documents obtained by cnn, the school said florida's taxpayers should not be held financially liable to mr. champion's estate for the ultimate results of his own imprudent, avoidable and tragic decision in death. champion collapsed and died shortly after a ritual in which pledges would run down the aisle of the bus and being punched. 14 have been charged in connection of his death. eamon al zawiya hee spoke exclusively to cnn's nick robertson and submitted a six-page plan calling for a ten-year truce with islamists, promising to stop provoking and attacking the u.s. if the u.s. ends war on islam and releases all islamist prisoners. as nick points out, the dplands
4:31pm
are similar to a 2004 proposal by osama bin laden. >> it wasn't accepted and after 2004, came the attack in london in 2005. is your proposal like this? if it isn't accepted, then there's more attacks? >> translator: i am sorry to say that those who caused the london attacks were the west, because the oppression continues. either you stop the oppression or accept the reconciliation. or then how are we supposed to convince the people? how do i convince others to stop? if the oppression and violence continues? >> muhammad al zawahiri says his brother will listen to him but says they have not talked in a deck indicate. it's been 404 days since the united states lost its top credit rating. what are we doing to get it back? sadly, not much today, which brings us to our third story. moody's warned today it could follow in the footsteps of standard & poor's and downgrade america's credit rating if congress doesn't start dealing
4:32pm
with the nation's debt problem. but how? today leaders couldn't even agree on whether a deal is possible to avoid the fiscal cliff to begin with. >> of well, i'm not confident at all. >> i'm confident we will reach some kind of arrangement. >> okay. we can't even agree on whether we're confident. and it's not funny, okay? if there is no action from congress, going over the fiscal cliff means spending get cut, that's for sure, all right? the bush tax cuts will go away. $1.2 trillion in automatic spending cuts will take effect. payroll taxes will go up. and emergency unemployment benefits will end. this will all hit in january. economists we have spoken with all have said this will lead to a recession. the congressional budget office says it could mean unemployment surges to 9% next year. if we avoid the cliff by extending some of the tax cuts or delaying or completely dodging the sequester, we sure don't address the debt problem, because we're spending a lot of borrowed money to pay for those things. so we're sort of left with a
4:33pm
choice between two evils. which the next president will have to address. "outfront" tonight is part of cnn's in depth look at the issues, senator rob portman, republican of the swing state of ohio, romney adviser, also a member of the super committee that failed to reach an agreement, oh, that led us to the whole sequester to begin with, senator. let me start with this. so obviously today pretty frustrating when you here one side confident, the other side not. and i'm sure they'll flip on that many times. but mitt romney blamed the president and republicans in congress for the deal that created the automatic budget cuts. i wanted to play what he said and get your response. here he is. >> i thought it was a mistake on the part of the white house to propose it. i think it was a mistake for republicans to go along with it. >> now, you voted in favor of the budget control act that said, look, if the super committee failed we need to have the sequester in motion. you said it was the first step to restore fiscal sanity, in your words. is mitt romney right to place the blame on you?
4:34pm
>> i don't think he's placing the blame on anyone. what he's saying is it's time for leadership. and what he's offering is real leadership to not just get our spending under control but put in place the pro growth controls to get the economy moving. i personally think, erin, there is a solution here and i think it makes a lot of sense. one is to go ahead and put in place for the first year the spending reductions part of this longer ten-year spending reduction trap. we can do that. there is a proposal out to do it. it's roughly $100 billion of spending reductions out of a $3 trillion budget that would occur immediately. and then with regard to the tax relief, for a short extension, in order to move to tax reform, we would avoid this fiscal cliff that's being talked about. so i think there is a way to do this. i'm not sure if it can be done before the election. i certainly think it should be. but it certainly could be done right after the election, regardless of what happens during the election, what they call the lame duck session of congress. and let's avoid this fiscal cliff. there is no reason to go over the cliff as some suggest we
4:35pm
ought to do. some suggest is this would be good for the country somehow. it would be terrible for the country. >> you have the super committee and you all couldn't come to an agreement. and the failure of that was supposed to lead to something awful, right? the sequester. so that's kind of -- that was the whole point. i mean, now people are trying to say let's switch the way the sequester was set up, and i mean -- if you're a ratings agency or someone around the world, it kind of looks like we don't know where we're going. >> well, i -- as you may have heard me say before, i don't think the sequester worked and therefore i don't think it was a good idea. and i was in those meetings and i can tell you republicans looked at this and said gee, there are no tax increases and we get the savings we were asked to find. and gosh, there are defense cuts which we wanted to do for decades this may not be a bad deal for us. so i think not having the sequester in place would have made it more likely we could have come up with an agreement. i don't think it was very effective. >> but you voted for it at the time. >> well, you know, there were a
4:36pm
lot of different aspects to that agreement. i thought it was a good idea for us to deal with the deficit and debt in order to raise the debt limit, which is what this was all about. i think it was -- it's much more important we deal with these long-term problems, including the mandatory spending side, which as you know, erin, is about two-thirds of our spending now. and it's the fastest-growing part of our spending. and that wasn't dealt with at all with this sequester. so i don't think it was a very effective tool. i think at this point, though, we are who we are, let's look at the year-end fiscal cliff and the problems that will result. and let's deal with it. let's come up with some of the spending reductions necessary for this first year to meet the requirements of the sequestrati sequestration. there are ways we can do that. again, over $3 trillion budget, we can come up with roughly the $100 billion needed. and let's also put in place a short-term extension of the existing tax code. and for me, that would be until july 4th. i like that date, because it's independence day, and during at time, let's force congress to get its job done. let's go to work right after the first of the year. >> one final question, though. because i know you're going to be playing on barack obama getting ready with mitt romney
4:37pm
for the debates. and one question that hopefully will come up, is asking mitt romney this. he didn't agree on a sequester, as he just said. he wants to increase defense spending to 4% of gdp. one estimate says that would be another $100 billion. we're not spending now extra in 2013. he wts to keep some of the benefits of the health care reform. he said the other day, including people staying on, their parents' insurance and preexisting conditions. but he wants to get rid of the individual mandate. he wants to cut taxes by 20%. i could add all that up and say my gosh, this guy is not a fisc fiscal conservative. he's going spend a whole lot more money. >> well, erin, i think there has been some misunderstanding about some of his plans and the biggest one is the tax relief you talked about. he's not talking about tax kwuts of 20%, he's talking about reducing the marginal rate to 20%, in a revenue-neutral way. it's not a tax cut, it's tax reform. and economists across the spectrum, right, left or center, will tell you that's going to grow the economy and create jobs. as a result, his tax reform has
4:38pm
been analyzed, increase economic growth to the point that 7 million new jobs will be created over the next ten years. so it is responsible. why? because it's -- >> what about defense spending and what about the health care? those are extra spends. obviously, the tax thing is a separate debate. but what about those things? how do we pay for that? >> well, regard to the defense spending, the 4% is roughly the historic average so he's talking about keeping defense roughly where it is. not having the wars in iraq and afghan stab help but an underlying defense budget of 4%. i think we're 3.8% now. without the extra costs for the wars. and then finally, with regard to health care, huge savings there. obviously, if you don't do the obamacare proposal, you save hundreds ofs about of dollars. >> but he's keeping some of the expensive benefits, isn't he? preexisting conditions and young people staying on their parents' plans. >> the biggest cost is setting up exchanges and huge subsidies and the number of people likely to join the exchanges, and frankly, lose their own private insurance to come to them and the utilization there and the
4:39pm
expansions of the government programs, including the huge expansion of medicaid. so that's where the big numbers are. and what governor romney has said from the start is that he thinks we should not go there, and therefore we'll have some big savings there. so the key is really very simple to me. one, you've got to reduce spending and governor romney is committed to do that. the fiscal hold that washington has got itself in is so deep, erin, you can't get out it just with spending cuts alone or growth alone. you need to do both. and that growth has to come from pro growth policies. he's not talking tax cuts. he's talking tax reform, because it will create more jobs, more growth and therefore more revenue. >> closing loopholes. thank you very much, senator. appreciate you taking the time. obviously what you heard from him, everyone is what you should expect to hear from mitt romney in some of these debates when these questions get put to him. this is going to be an interesting next month. four fourth story "outfro " "outfront," big question tonight, united states versus israel. israeli sources telling our wolf blitzer today, at least for now,
4:40pm
the white house has rejected a request from prime minister benjamin netanyahu meet with president obama this month. they wanted to discuss iran's disputed nuclear program while in the united states for the key annual meeting. and netanyahu is getting increasingly frustrated with the united states for not drawing a so-called red line when it comes to iran's nuclear program, saying the u.s. hazard no quote moral right from taking military action on its own. "outfront" tonight, elise labott. elise, this seems like it's wrapped up more and more from the israeli side, they want the world to know the u.s. is not standing where they think it should be standing. >> reporter:el well, i think, erin, a couple things are going ton. prime minister netanyahu asked for this meeting with president obama on the same day that he was making some very tough comments about what he conceives as foot-dragging by the obama administration when it comes to iran.
4:41pm
secretary of state hillary clinton made some comments to a news reporter earlier over the weekend, saying that the u.s. is not going to impose any deadlines on iran. and so prime minister netanyahu didn't like that. he started talking yesterday in some other interviews and today. and so on the same day he asked for the interview, u.s. kind of looks like the white house was trying to put him in his place by saying we don't know what the schedule will allow. but there's no love lost between these two leaders. every time they're scheduled to meet, there is tension about whether there should be a meeting. this is really no surprise that the white house would shy away from giving prime minister netanyahu a firm date for a meeting. they're pretty pissed off. >> elise, one more question. we obviously reported the breaking news here on the show about an american being killed in libya and the consulate today, as there were protests there and in cairo at the american consulates and embassies. what can you tell us about what you've heard happen there in
4:42pm
libya? >> reporter: well, the situation, erin, is very fluid, and information is still coming in fast and furious. what we understand, several armed gunmen breached the consulate compound and tried to get into the consulate. what the u.s. is hearing from the libyan interior ministry is that an american was killed. but, you know, the u.s. very careful to confirm the death of an american until it receives independent confirmation, until, to be crass, sees the body themselves, they're not going to say an american was killed. obviously, it's a very small counselors lot in benghazi, they want to notify next of kin. so there are some reports coming out that a u.s. consulate official was killed and the u.s. is trying to find that out. but still, they're trying to secure the compound. this came after those protested cairo, obviously kind of took everybody by surprise. but it doesn't look like it's 100% secure yet. >> wow, certainly shocking and upsetting headline with an american dead tonight in libya. ahead, the secret science
4:43pm
used by campaigns to get your vote. they know much more than you would ever want them to know about you. if there was a pill to help protect your eye health as you age... would you take it? well, there is. [ male announcer ] it's called ocuvite. a vitamin totally dedicated to your eyes, from the eye-care experts at bausch + lomb. as you age, eyes can lose vital nutrients. ocuvite helps replenish key eye nutrients. [ male announcer ] ocuvite has a unique formula not found in your multivitamin to help protect your eye health. now, that's a pill worth taking.
4:44pm
[ male announcer ] ocuvite. help protect your eye health. throughout our lives. one a day women's 50+ is a complete multivitamin designed for women's health concerns as we age. it has more of 7 antioxidants to support cell health. one a day 50+.
4:45pm
to support cell health. [ female announcer ] some people like to pretend a flood could never happen to them. and that their homeowners insurance protects them. [ thunder crashes ] it doesn't. stop pretending. only flood insurance covers floods. ♪ visit floodsmart.gov/pretend to learn your risk.
4:46pm
and now our fifth story "outfront." the money ball of politics.
4:47pm
so when you hear the words "money and politics," you probably think of, well, nothing good. but among the things you think of, campaign commercials, there have been nearly a half billion dollars spent so far this presidential campaign alone. it is a stunning number and slated to go higher and higher and higher. you also, obviously, probably think about those expensive and lavishly planned conventions that brought us moments like these. >> it's the genius of the american free enterprise system to harness the creativity and talent and industry of the american people with a system that's dedicated to creating tomorrow's prosperity. not trying to redistribute today's. >> if you believe in a country where everyone gets a fair shot, and everyone does their fair share, and everyone plays by the same rules, then i need you to vote this november. >> every moment of those things is choreographed, the signs they
4:48pm
hand out to wave around, everything are works of art. but do they really determine who you vote for? sasha eisenberg, author of the new book, "the victory lab" which uncovers the secret science to winning campaigns. first off, they know a lot about us. we've all gotten used to feeling like people are spying on us online but how much do they really know, campaigns, about us? >> probably thousands of individual data points, and that can be your registration record, your name, gender, address, things they derive from what the census tells you about the neighborhood. and then information from past political campaigns. so if a candidate came to your door in 1996 and ask what you thought of bob dole, that's in a database somewhere and being used this year. and tons of information from commercial data warehouses, the types of people that put together the information that allow companies to make credit scores or do direct mail targeting for at that time logs is being used. >> so you buy something from one store and you get things in your e-mail box and say, gosh -- sometimes you can kind of trace it back in your own head.
4:49pm
but they're able to buy into that databases so you know what clothes you like and shop and all that stuff. >> fill out a warranty card and say your household income is between 50 and $100,000 and if you took a cruise they know that too. a lot of variables tell us nothing about politics. but when you have thousands of them, you can start to see which actually do predict it. and so they use these algorithms that allow them to basically look for patterns as to which variables are helpful in predicting political behaviors. and it is the same type of thing companies do with credit scores, so campaigns, instead of predicting when you're going to default on your loan or whether you're going to pay off your bill in a given month or run up several hundred dollars in charges, they're going to predict are you going to cast a ballot, vote for barack obama, mitt romney, are you pro choice. >> so they run all these algorith algorithms, very scientist. and using it to get their base out. so the first use of it is i know sasha is going to vote, let's
4:50pm
just say for the purposes of this conversation, democrat. he always has. but i'm going to force him to do it. i'm going to guilt him into it? >> yeah, a lost tools people are using to motivate are using to motivate their base are grounded in ideas of behavior psychology. the most effective tool ever used, where they randomly assigned voters different treatments and one was a record of vote history. it was say, dear erin, your vote history is a matter of public record. you voted in 2010, you didn't vote in the school board election. there's an election coming up and we'll send everybody an updated send. >> they do the catholic jewish mother. what if you're someone that is pro choice, you want to target someone who you think is persuadable because they're theoretically on one side and the other on issues they care about. any example of how someone has bridged that divide?
4:51pm
>> in 2010, some outside groups working on harry reid's behalf took information from ballot initiatives about marijuana legalization and were able to find precincts were there were huge concentrations of libertarians. they targeted her about her record on women's issues and abortion where they were able to cross cut and find social issues and stay away from the fiscal stuff. >> and they were successfully able to win those precincts. >> yeah. >> is this more effective than the -- what we're hearing about a billion dollar plus campaign, that's the number that's been thrown out there, and these are blast ads, so you're hitting a
4:52pm
wide net. is that more effective? >> everything that's happened in the past decade is taking these large categories, a broad demographic, and starting to think about individuals. >> all right. next, we remember. than 550 mils you'll inevitably find yourself on a desolate highway in your jeep grand cherokee. and when you do, you'll be grateful for the adaptive cruise control that automatically adjusts your speed when approaching slower traffic. and for the blind-spot monitor... [ beeping ] ...that helps remind you that the highway might not be as desolate... as you thought. ♪
4:53pm
how did i get here? dumb luck? or good decisions? ones i've made. ones we've all made. about marriage. children.
4:54pm
money. about tomorrow. here's to good decisions. who matters most to you says the most about you. massmutual is owned by our policyholders so they matter most to us. massmutual. we'll help you get there. see life in the best light. [music] transitions® lenses automatically filter just the right amount of light. so you see everything the way it's meant to be seen. experience life well lit, ask for transitions adaptive lenses.
4:55pm
4:56pm
more on the breaking news story we brought you. a state department official tells cnn the united states has been notified by the libyan government that an american consulate official was killed in benghazi today. the state department doesn't have independent confirmation of the death, but it is the result of a day of violence against americans in the middle east. protesters scaled the walls of the u.s. embassy in cairo and burned american flags, this in response to a video produced by an american mocking the prophet muhammad. we're joined now on the phone. we have new video we'll be showing you here as we ask you -- i know you've been in touch with people on the ground.
4:57pm
we're looking at new video here in benghazi. what can you tell us happened? >> reporter: well, there are reports of libyan casualties as a result of these clashes at the consulate. i spoke to eye witnesses on the scene who described the situation there. libyan security forces were engaged in heavy clashes with members of an armed group, a radical militant group based in eastern libya. libyan troops were deployed to the scene. roads to the consulate were blocked. rocket-propelled grenades were fired at the consulate building. an official is telling cnn that the building is being secured by the libyan military, but we're hearing from eye witnesses in benghazi that members of the armed group had taken over the consulate building and were
4:58pm
celebrating and looting the consulate. there's been condemnation here by regular libyans and officials and also calls on social media sites for more protests in benghazi and here in the capital tripoli. >> reporting live from tripoli tonight. thank you very much. it is the 11th anniversary of the september 11 attacks, which nearly 3,000 people were killed. ceremonies were held at the world trade center, the pentagon, pennsylvania, the white house, and arlington national cemetery. even though we're more than a decade removed from those attacks, for many americans, especially the families of those who died, the emotions will always be as raw as they were at the beginning. but we were discussing what september 11 will mean to future generations. it's hard to think about that,
4:59pm
but it will happen. so today i was thinking of my visit to the "uss arizona." the ship attacked in pearl harbor in 1941. i wasn't alive when pearl harbor changed the world, but i visited the memorial in hawaii a uple of times and it is a moving and somber event. it made me feel american patriotism in a special way. it lets people, generations removed from a transformative moment in our history, imagine it, connect with it. it helps us remember and unites us as americans. they have video of that day. you can imagine what it was like to be someone there in the navy and out on your day of leave and you go back for your night and it brings it alive in a way that is so important. one day ground zero will be like hawaii's arizona. a part of history that a memorial and museum made poignant t